“Art does not reproduce the visible, it makes visible,” wrote the expressionist painter Paul Klee. The same could be said about perfumery, which is an art of intangible substances. The greatest fragrances conjure up the most complex of images, holding the artistic intent of their creators and offering a glimpse into their thoughts and memories. Of course, the goal of a perfumer may not always be that grand (or, given the nature of the market today, they may have neither the time nor opportunity to leave their fingerprint on a finished fragrance). However, when it does happen and a perfume feels more than the sum of its parts, it can touch us as deeply as any great work of art.
One of my favorite examples is Lalique’s Encre Noire Pour Homme released in 2006, and which perfumer Nathalie Lorson composed with the intention of showing off the suave, languid character of vetiver – a note usually seen as bracing and cold. A type of grass originating in India, Vetiver is grown to prevent soil erosion and produces a complex oil with accents of licorice, bitter grapefruit peel, smoke, and damp earth. Everything that makes it interesting is present in Encre Noire, but Lorson went further. She balanced the different facets of vetiver and highlighted them with musk and woods, fashioning the roughness of roots into reams of black silk.
Jean-Claude Ellena is another perfumer whose fragrances illustrate Klee’s point. In his books Perfume: The Alchemy of Scent and The Diary of a Nose he explains how in his compositions he seeks not to reproduce nature but to communicate his own ideas about it. His voyage into vetiver, Terre d’Hermès, moves away from the roughhewn image of roots and explores their often forgotten crisp, mineral nuances. The perfume’s refinement and its luminous take on woody notes make it one of Ellena’s most original compositions.
Another vetiver interpretation, halfway between the dark richness of Lalique’s Encre Noire and the mineral brightness of Terre d’Hermès, is the Pour Elle version of Encre Noire. (Although the Pour Homme and Pour Elle designations should be treated as mere guidelines; both versions can be worn by men and women.) Encre Noire Pour Elle was created by Christine Nagel, who today works alongside Ellena as an in-house perfumer for Hermès. The fragrance is her vetiver, which she sees as soft as cashmere. Nagel peels back the woody, salty layers and sprinkles the milky green heart of vetiver with violets and roses. The result is unexpected, but all the more memorable for it.
Do you wear Encre Noire? What are your thoughts on this fragrance?
7 Comments
Princess Tonk: Ive never been a green person BUT Encre Noire pour homme and Jacobo Silences are my loves. August 9, 2024 at 10:17am
Gabriela: Thank you for reminding me of this beauty. Just found it online for 20€ here in Europe, such a bargain!
My favourite vetiver is Vetiver Tonka, I treasure my sample. August 9, 2024 at 11:22am
Jocelan: Yes, Encore Noir Pour Elle has been my signature fragrance ever since it was released. I love how it works with my chemistry and the fact that no one else i know wears it. So elegant and classic with a touch of mystery that continues to surprise me, even after all these years. August 9, 2024 at 12:37pm
Klaas: Encre Noire sure is a wonderful fragrance! I gave it to my mom a few years ago, she’s 83 years old now and she wears it through fall and winter. It gives her such an edge! I love wearing it, too, but my own favorite vetiver is La Route du Vétiver by Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier. It’s a introvert, brooding fragrance and, like Encre Noire, quite complex.
Have you been able to smell the new-ish Encre Bleu flanker? The bottle is gorgeous but I don’t trust the fragrance somehow……Could I tempt you to write a review? August 9, 2024 at 3:04pm
Eric Harris: Thank you for the lovely article! For Vetiver, I reach for Lubin’s Le Vetyver, which creates a soaring airy Vetiver brace with incense. It’s like filling your lungs with cold fresh air. August 9, 2024 at 8:51pm
Hilde: Coincidently, this weekend – this was before I read your post – I took out my Encre Noir pour homme bottle out of my shelves.
Not to put it on, but to give me an idea again of how vetiver smells.
The inducement for it was to try to detect the different components in a room spray of RainPharma named ‘Nature après la Pluie’ that is composed of natural essential oils, wherein mentha piperita, pogostemon cablin leaf (patchouli), salvia officinalis, vetiveria zizanoides root and rosmarinus officinalis. August 12, 2024 at 2:57am
Amy B: I blind bought a full bottle because of your descriptions of Encre Noir! And I love it. August 15, 2024 at 12:17pm