Nelly Rodi 5-8 : Perfume Reviews by Tania Sanchez

MogulSee Tania’s reviews of Nelly Rodi’s 1-4.

My cold was even worse when I tested these than the previous four. Therefore, forgive what is bound to be bad smelling on my part. Instead, pay attention to the ravings of my poor husband, forced to cough up opinions on smells when he’d rather be watching Most Extreme Elimination Challenge.

The first flare is a big bright citrus and ginger, reminiscent of Origins Ginger Essences, which gets me so excited, and then, just to upset me, it collapses immediately into an ordinary cloying fruity-floral grapefruit-rose with an unnecessarily heavy amber base and a bit of something like Thymes Ginger Milk trying without much success to be heard. Why, oh, why? Naturally, this is the strongest, most powerful scent in the whole batch. I can’t even wash it off.

Second opinion from the husband, after forcing him to sniff my knee: “It’s like a flower arrangement in a bar.”

“Why in a bar? Do you smell vomit?”

“No, it’s kind of a smoke under it…or bourbon.”

#6: BOIS Leather! Smoke! Cigarette! A little sweetness! In fact, you know what this smells a little bit like? Bulgari Black. But sweeter, and with a grassy oomph under it. Not as dry.

Husband [top notes]: “A whole pack of fruity Lifesavers! But not just the candy…the wax wrapper, too!”

Husband [15 minutes in]: “Oh, the Lifesavers are gone. It’s like…nice. I don’t know. Nice. I like it.”

Me: “C’mon!”

Husband: “OK, OK. It’s like…this vanilla sweetness, this kind of desserty, but way up high, like, above it, high up, is this thing like a bug zapper.”

Husband: “You know, like a bug zapper? Like the smell of a bug zapper?”

Me: “No.”

Husband [1 hour in]: “Oh, it’s totally different now. You know, I think that bug zapper thing was like some kind of ozone smell I was picking up. But now it’s gone. Now it’s just…nice.”

Me [offering him an arm with Bulgari Black for contrast]: “Does it smell like this?”

Husband: “No, this is sweeter, more floral. Stronger. I like it! I just like it! It’s nice!”

This is the weirdest amber ever. It smells a little like browned butter, a little like smoky candle wax. The effect is dark, sweet, oily, a little scorched, and sort of unpleasant. I usually like amber, but not this time.

Husband [forced to smell my knee]: “It’s sweet, right, but it reminds me of a scent they would put in toys that were supposed to smell nice, like My Little Pony or something. Something pleasant and longlasting and banal that would work with plastic. I don’t like it as much as the other one [Bois].”

#8: ROSE
I forgot to try this one. I feel dumb.

All in all, I must say that the set as a whole is heavy on the topnotes, weak in the development. I’m guessing it’s meant to sell based on a few quick sniffs. The scents aren’t necessarily bad. They simply aren’t made to last. The standouts for me were Incense and Bois, but on the whole, I wasn’t inspired by most of them. If I could buy just Incense, though, I would in a heartbeat.

At $145 for the set of eight, the bottles average out to about $18 and change each. Not that bad. But keep in mind that for EDPs, they aren’t that strong. They’re still selling, though. The first day Aedes got this set in, they had a dozen for sale, and by the end of the day, they had two. (I was told that more were coming in the next shipment.) It’s fun to sniff it if you can get to Aedes. And I do recommend you get to Aedes. That place is heaven, if heaven had samples.

Painting: The mighty Mogul emperors. (Left to Right) Jahangir, Akbar the great, and Shah Jahan (who built the Taj Mahal). kalranga/mogul/2372.htm



  • parislondres: Fun reviews T! No. 6 Bois sounds interesting to me. Not sure about the other three. September 9, 2005 at 1:38am Reply

  • Robin: Your husband is a trooper! Tried to get my dh to smell #6 last night. His comment: “Smells like wood”. Uh, thanks. September 9, 2005 at 10:42am Reply

  • mreenymo: T, I think you got to the nub of it: These fragrance sets will sell because one gets that first “hit” of the topnote, is captivated and thinks, “What the heck, these are cool, I’ll buy them!” What a great marketing strategy, especially for inpatient, “gotta have it now!” Americans.

    I love your husband’s comments. Sounds like he knows how to get to the nub of things, too. 🙂 September 9, 2005 at 12:18pm Reply

  • BoisdeJasmin: T, your husband’s comments are priceless. Every time I read this post, I start laughing out loud. September 9, 2005 at 11:19am Reply

  • Tania: R & V: Will is the best! He finds my little hobby really entertaining. We like to sit around and compare impressions. He comes up with some weird associations.

    Neela: Bois was lovely, cozy and smoky. I wish they sold them separately. Would’ve been nice to try the Rose but I had no room left on my considerably scented person. I’m glad V & R managed to get some excellent reviews in. And they had the benefit of full use of their own noses, too! September 9, 2005 at 12:12pm Reply

What do you think?

From the Archives

Latest Comments

  • Sebastian in Recommend Me a Perfume : October 2020: Salome would interest you in the context of your question. It is a perfume that is reminiscent of the 70s, and in that time would have been considered definitely feminine. October 30, 2020 at 3:42am

  • Ninon in Recommend Me a Perfume : October 2020: Hello Peter! Anubis is on my to-try list, I think perhaps because of your recommendation (unfortunately the samples are currently out of stock at LS). I do not usually get… October 30, 2020 at 1:23am

  • Ninon in Recommend Me a Perfume : October 2020: Totally agree–I’m another non rose person who loves Mohur, especially the extrait. The other “rose” I like is Une Rose de Kandahar, but it’s really more about almond, apricot, tobacco,… October 30, 2020 at 1:19am

  • Peter in Recommend Me a Perfume : October 2020: Hello Ninon. Have you tried any of Liz Moores’ Papillon perfumes? Salome is a slightly skanky retro potion. Fragrantica classifies it as a Chypre Floral with woody, leather, musky, white… October 29, 2020 at 11:04pm

Latest Tweets

Design by cre8d
© Copyright 2005-2020 Bois de Jasmin. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy